Let's do another little comparison here, since the last one was so much fun!
I was listening to an old Son house cd the other day, and it struck me just how much his voice reminded me of Ralph Stanley's.
Of course, they both play very different types of music, but when I started to think about it, they have an awful lot in common.
First up, Dr. Ralph Stanley:
Ralph has a very distinct mountain style that really takes one back to the hills. I've heard folks say that his is the best/purest bluegrass voice.
For years, he only sang harmony, preferring to let his brother Carter take all lead vocals. Since Carter Stanley's death in 1966, Ralph has sang lead, and duetted with just about everyone in the old time community you could possibly imagine.
Ralph is also known for his slashing banjo style. He started out playing clawhammer, but after hearing Earl Scruggs, switched over to three finger style.
Seems like Ralph has always been in someone elses shadow. Always content to let his brother sing lead, and playing bluegrass banjo while Earl still walks the face of the earth.
Then, there's Son House:
Huge voice.
Son, too, lived in the shadow of somebody else. Apparently Charlie Patton taught Son how to play guitar, and although he (Charlie) is my favorite of the old guys, I've gotta admit that Son had the better voice.
Son appeared to be a bitter man. Seemed that any chance he had to bad mouth Patton, he took. I guess he was jealous. I've read that he was constantly taking pot shots at Patton's 'clownin'.
Patton, as anybody who's listened to him knows, was a whiz with a guitar (yes, I think he was better than Robert johnson) and took to playing his guitar behind his head, and between his legs, among other things. You coulda' called him the first Jimi Hendrix.
I think that Son, although a rudimentry guitarist, was one of the blues' greatest voices.
^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^
Now, compare Son singing John the Revelator to Ralph Stanley singing Oh Death. Neat, huh?
Both men sing with a hell of a lot of natural soul. At times Ralph sounds like a blues singer, and at times, Son House sounds like a mountain singer.
You can't teach that stuff. It just flows outta both of them.